Skip to main content
University of California Press

About the Book

Twelve distinguished historians, political theorists, and literary critics present new perspectives on multiculturalism in this important collection. Central to the essays (all but one is appearing in print for the first time) is the question of how the Jewish experience can challenge the conventional polar opposition between a majority "white monoculture" and a marginalized "minorities of color multiculture." This book takes issue with such a dichotomy by showing how experiences of American Jews can undo conventional categories. Neither a complaint against multiculturalism by Jews who feel excluded from it, nor a celebration of multiculturalism as the solution to contemporary Jewish problems, Insider/Outsider explores how the Jews' anomalous status opens up multicultural history in different and interesting directions. The goal of the editors has been to transcend the notion of "comparative victimology" and to show the value of a narrative that does not rely on competing histories of persecution. Readers can discover in these essays arguments that will broaden their understanding of Jewish identity and multicultural theory and will enliven the contemporary debate about American culture generally.

About the Author

David Biale is Professor of Jewish Studies, Graduate Theological Union, Berkeley. Michael Galchinsky is Professor of English at Millsaps College in Jackson, Mississippi. Susannah Heschel is Associate Professor of Judaic Studies at Case Western University.

Table of Contents

INTRODUCTION: The Dialectic ofJewish Enlightenment
David Biale, Michael Galchinsky, and Susannah Heschel
I: AMERICAN SYMPHONY OR MELTING POT?
1.The Melting Pot and Beyond: Jews and the Politics of American Identity 
David Biale
2.In Defense of Shaatnez: A Politics for Jews in a Multicultural America 
Mitchell Cohen
3·Pluralism and Its Discontents: The Case of Blacks and Jews 
Cheryl Greenberg
4·Multiculturalism and the Politics of Interest 
Michael Walzer
II: CANONS AND COUNTERHISTORIES
5·Jewish Studies as Counterhistory 
Susannah Heschel
6.The Paradox of Jewish Studies in the New Academy 
Sara R. Horowitz
7·The Double Canonicity of the Hebrew Bible 
Robert Alter
8.The Idea of Judaism in Feminism and Afrocentrism
Amy Newman
III: DIASPORA NEGOTIATIONS
9-Scattered Seeds: A Dialogue of Diasporas 
Michael Galchinsky
1O.Language as Homeland in Jewish-American Literature 
Hana Wirth-Nesher
11.Modernism and Exile: A View from the Margins 
Michael Gluzman
12.Fag-Hags and Bu-Jews: Toward a (Jewish) Politics of Vicarious Identity 
Naomi Seidman
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS 
INDEX 

Reviews

"Invaluable reading for anyone interested in multiculturalism."—Julius Lester, author of Lovesong

"I know of no other work that, through numerous insights and useful distinctions, so alerts us to and comprehensively documents the ongoing constitutive role of Christian and anti-semitic perceptions of Jewish existence and the interactions between them. Whereas much contemporary historiography has become so specialized that historians have surrendered the larger picture, Biale's panoramic perspective reveals the great value and interest of this work."—Steven E. Aschheim, author of Beyond the Border: The German-Jewish Legacy Abroad