Skip to main content
University of California Press

About the Book

Why does a country with religious liberty enmeshed in its legal and social structures produce such overt prejudice and discrimination against Muslims? Sahar Aziz’s groundbreaking book demonstrates how race and religion intersect to create what she calls the Racial Muslim. Comparing discrimination against immigrant Muslims with the prejudicial treatment of Jews, Catholics, Mormons, and African American Muslims during the twentieth century, Aziz explores the gap between America’s aspiration for and fulfillment of religious freedom. With America’s demographics rapidly changing from a majority white Protestant nation to a multiracial, multireligious society, this book is an in dispensable read for understanding how our past continues to shape our present—to the detriment of our nation’s future.

About the Author

Sahar Aziz is Professor of Law, Middle East Legal Scholar, and Chancellor’s Social Justice Scholar at Rutgers University Law School and Founding Director of the Center for Security, Race, and Rights.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments
Foreword by John L. Esposito

Introduction
1 • When American Racism Quashes Religious Freedom
2 • The Color of Religion
3 • Racialization of Jews, Catholics, and Mormons in the Twentieth Century
4 • From Protestant to Judeo-Christian National Identity: The Expansion of American Whiteness
5 • Social Construction of the Racial Muslim
6 • American Orientalism and the Arab Terrorist Trope
7 • Fighting Terrorism, Not Religion
8 • Officiating Islamophobia
9 • Criminalizing Muslim Identity
10 • The Future of the Racial Muslim and Religious Freedom in America
Conclusion

Notes
Bibliography
Index

Reviews

“Thought-provoking.”

Above the Law
"The Racial Muslim is an important, timely addition to the literature on anti-Muslim racism. Aziz succinctly compresses a broad, yet relevant, range of topics into a relatively short text, all-the-while interrogating power, White supremacy, structural racism and the intersection of religion and race in racializing processes."
Ethnic and Racial Studies
"From her law professor perspective with an interdisciplinary approach, Aziz’s work recalls that of Kimberley Crenshaw, in which juridical science is combined with social sciences to achieve change: indeed, her work is not limited to the analysis of society, but seeks as an ultimate goal, social justice."
ReOrient
"Aziz unravels and then connects America’s torrid history toward religious minorities."
Journal of Church and State
"The book explicates narratives concerning Muslims’ inability to assimilate or that assert Islam is merely a political ideology and promotes tactics to abrogate religious liberty." 
 
the Journal of Church and State
"The insights of this work culminate in a powerful analytic for understanding religious discrimination. This book is destined to have a long shelf life and an increase in influence, particularly as its main tenets are deployed to analyze religious repression in contexts beyond the United States." - Spear It, Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly. 

"Professor Sahar Aziz’s book offers an illuminating account of the immigrant Muslim experience in the United States, but it does more than that. It provides readers with an opportunity to reflect on whether a narrative of race and racialization remains the most powerful way to understand proliferating differences in the United States." - Rachel F. Moran, Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly. 

"The Racial Muslim is an invaluable resource for anyone interested in the dynamics of race and how they intersect with religion. . . . essential reading for anyone concerned with racial and religious justice in the United States." - Natsu Taylor Saito, Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly. 
Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly

"Sahar Aziz deftly examines the peculiar place of Muslims in the American imagination, studying a religious minority that has been treated as a racial minority, objectified as terrorist, denied the religious freedom our tradition celebrates, and instead subjected to the profiling, monitoring, and policing that our tradition has too often practiced. An essential book for understanding how American law and culture have constructed an image of the Muslim that bears no resemblance to reality and betrays our failure to practice what we preach."—David Cole, National Legal Director, ACLU, and author of Enemy Aliens: Double Standards and Constitutional Freedoms in the War on Terrorism

The Racial Muslim provides the crucial historical and legal background of the links between white Protestant Christian supremacy in the US—which racialized not only Native Americans and African Americans as inferior but also American Catholics, Jews, and Mormons, not to mention East Asian immigrants—and the ongoing racialization in the US of Muslim immigrants and their American descendants. Meticulously researched and seamlessly written, Aziz’s book is crucial for all those concerned with how race and religion remain completely intertwined in American law and society today and how they are weaponized against American Muslims.”—Joseph Massad, Professor of Modern Arab Politics and Intellectual History at Columbia University and author of Islam in Liberalism

"Aziz has written a fabulous book that highlights the inherent paradox that exists in America between commitment to religious freedom and rising levels of Islamophobia. Aziz traces the historical developments that produce today’s Racial Muslim. With sophisticated insights and empirical cases, Aziz unpacks the social and legal historical processes that reinforce the status quo. This book is a wonderful addition to the scholarship on Muslims in America."—Amaney A. Jamal, Professor of Politics at Princeton University and author of Of Empires and Citizens: Pro-American Democracy or No Democracy at All?

"While Trump’s immigration rules targeting and excluding Muslim immigration were widely denounced, the origins of this travesty and other related anti-Muslim policies have not been fully excavated. The Racial Muslim performs this essential work in mapping how Muslim religious identity is racialized. Identifying the roles of distinct forms of Orientalism, American empire, Christian religious hierarchy and anti-Black racism that shape the concept of Muslim as a racial identity, Aziz provides powerful insight into the ways in which forms of racialization evolve. This book provides invaluable lessons for resisting white supremacy as an enduring yet shape-shifting feature of the American story."—Cheryl Harris, Rosalinde and Arthur Gilbert Foundation Chair in Civil Rights and Civil Liberties at UCLA School of Law

"The Racial Muslim is a provocative argument and remarkable analysis of the connections and tensions between race and religion. Scholars like Sahar Aziz are more necessary than ever in these perilous times."—Ian F. Haney López, Chief Justice Earl Warren Professor of Public Law, University of California, Berkeley and author of Merge Left: Fusing Race and Class, Winning Elections, and Saving America

"In this wide-ranging study, Aziz elegantly tracks the intersections of religion and race in America, describing their historical entangling and meticulously demonstrating how that background has framed the current campaign against Muslims in America and led to the normalization of a racial Islamophobia. This is strong scholarship, brimming with insight and perfectly timed for the current American conversation about race and religion."—John Corrigan, Lucius Moody Bristol Distinguished Professor of Religion and History at Florida State University

"Deftly weaving her exhaustive research on the discrimination faced by Catholic, Mormon and Jewish Americans through the course of our history with the Islamophobia of recent decades, Professor Aziz powerfully highlights the disparity between our noble ideals and the painful realities of intolerance that continue to plague our society.  With her cogent and sophisticated analysis, Professor Aziz seamlessly intertwines the past and the present to critique efforts at Protestant Christian hegemony with the perpetuation of anti-Black racism, anti-Semitism, Islamophobia and other forms of hate.  In the process, her intersectional understanding of the struggle for equality makes a vital contribution to the literature on issues of race, religion and discrimination.  The Racial Muslim is a clarion call warning us that, despite all of the progress we have made, the path to justice is not linear and there remains a great deal of work to be done."  —John Tehranian, Paul W. Wildman Chair and Professor of Law, Southwestern Law School, and author of Whitewashed: America's Invisible Middle Eastern Minority

"With a comprehensive eye, Sahar Aziz situates the current rash of Islamophobia in the long and troubled history of American race relations, and reminds us about how far we have not come. This will be the go-to volume on the topic for many years to come."—Tom Ginsburg, Leo Spitz Professor of International Law, Ludwig and Hilde Wolf Research Scholar, and Professor of Political Science at the University of Chicago Law School

"If a book needed to be written after the Trump presidency, it is this one. In this bold and compelling book, one of the foremost critical race scholars of our time analyzes the ways that the religious Muslim has become a suspect, if not a criminal, category in the American mind. Fluid, honest, insightful, and often dazzlingly brilliant, this book is a must read for anyone who cares about religious freedom, racism, and the future of the United States."—Khaled Abou El Fadl, Omar and Azmeralda Alfi Distinguished Professor of Law, UCLA School of Law

Awards

  • CHOICE Outstanding Academic Titles 2023 2023, Choice

Media

Author Sahar Aziz discusses her book, The Racial Muslim