Skip to main content
University of California Press

Who Will Lead Us?

The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America
by Samuel C. Heilman (Author)
Hardcover Paperback eBook
Price: $24.95 / £21.00
Publication Date: Jul 2019
Edition: 1st Edition
Title Details:
Rights: World
Pages: 336
ISBN: 9780520308404
Trim Size: 6 x 9
Illustrations: 24 b/w photographs
Request an Exam or Desk Copy(opens in new window)RightsLink(opens in new window)Read an Excerpt(opens in new window)
Recommend to your Library (PDF)(opens in new window)Rights and Permissions

About the Book

Hasidism, a movement many believed had passed its golden age, has had an extraordinary revival since it was nearly decimated in the Holocaust and repressed in the Soviet Union. Hasidic communities, now settled primarily in North America and Israel, have reversed the losses they suffered and are growing exponentially. With powerful attachments to the past, mysticism, community, tradition, and charismatic leadership, Hasidism seems the opposite of contemporary Western culture, yet it has thrived in the democratic countries and culture of the West. How? Who Will Lead Us? finds the answers to this question in the fascinating story of five contemporary Hasidic dynasties and their handling of the delicate issue of leadership and succession.
 
Revolving around the central figure of the rebbe, the book explores two dynasties with too few successors, two with too many successors, and one that believes their last rebbe continues to lead them even after his death. Samuel C. Heilman, recognized as a foremost expert on modern Jewish Orthodoxy, here provides outsiders with the essential guide to continuity in the Hasidic world.

About the Author

Samuel C. Heilman is Proshansky Chair in Jewish Studies at the Graduate Center and Distinguished Professor of Sociology at Queens College CUNY. He has written eleven books, including, most recently (with Menachem Friedman), The Rebbe: The Life and Afterlife of Menachem Mendel Schneerson, winner of the National Jewish Book Award.

Table of Contents

List of Illustrations
Prologue

1 Succession in Contemporary Hasidism: Who Will Lead Us?
2 Munkács: An Oedipal Challenge
3 Boyan and Kopyczynitz: Running Out of Rebbes
4 Bobov: A Clash of Families
5 Satmar: Succession Charged with Conflict
6 ChaBaD Lubavitch: A Rebbe Who Never Dies

Final Thoughts
Notes
Index

Reviews

"One might expect to find these riveting succession stories—of the rebbes of the Munkacs, Boyan and Kopyczynitz, Bobover, Satmar, and Chabad Lubavitch dynasties—in a TV mini-series rather than in a work of sociology and history. While fueled by an enormous amount of research, they read more like page turners where the obsession is not sex, but succession."
— Moment
"Riveting. . . . A great read!" 
— Haemtza
"An invaluable addition to the ranks of objective studies of a Jewish movement that continues to flourish in the U.S. even as more modern denominations decline."
— Publishers Weekly

"Anyone interested in Jewish history mixed with a bit of palace intrigue will enjoy this book.”

— Jewish Book Council
“...Heilman’s wellspring of facts and tidbits conveys empathy and sympathy to the old/new Hasidic yore on the American shore bounded by memory, defined by family genetics, and guided by a religion of law. . . . This is a well-researched tome.”
— Reading Religion
"Anyone interested in Jewish history mixed with a bit of palace intrigue will enjoy this book."
— Jewish Book Review
"Engrossing . . . . Required reading for anyone interested in the contemporary hasidic world."
— Seforim
"Who Will Lead Us? includes many great stories, all of them sharply and engagingly told. Heilman’s account of the fight over the leadership of the Bobovers (resolved after years of infighting by the New York State Supreme Court) is worth the price of the hard cover volume alone."
— Jewish Review of Books
“Heilman has drawn on many sources which he presents to us for the first time. He writes like a novelist thus making this a book that is hard to put down.”
— Reviews by Amos Lassen
"Once again, students of Judaism and religious traditionalism are indebted to Heilman for his brilliant and insightful work."
— Contemporary Jewry
"An in-depth analysis of how a very particular part of the Jewish world confronts modernity, post-Holocaust society, the modern nation-state of Israel, and a flourishing American Jewish community."
— CHOICE
"Fascinating. . . . This book is worthwhile for insights into these insular societies; societies that many may find inspiring."
— Association of Jewish Libraries Reviews
"Heilman is a master storyteller. . . .For readers interested in the internal dynamics of Hasidic communal life and in the adaptation of traditionalist Jewish groups to life in America, this book will be an enthralling and sometimes startling read."
— Religious Studies Review
“Who Will Lead Us? brilliantly demonstrates that the remarkable resurrection of Hasidism has been due to its capacity for maintaining the charismatic authority of its dynastic leadership. This is by far the most insightful study of the social, economic, and political dynamics of Hasidim today.”—Ada Rapoport-Albert, Professor Emerita of Jewish Studies at University College London
 
“What happens to dynasties when they meet America? This is a fascinating tale of the struggles over succession that plague today’s Hasidic communities. Told with a richness of detail and insider knowledge that only Samuel Heilman could muster.”—Art Green, Professor Emeritus of Near Eastern and Judaic Studies at Brandeis University
 
“Once again, Samuel Heilman has opened the opaque world of contemporary Hasidism to his readers. With a rare blend of historical depth and sociological breadth, he offers up five case studies that explore the fraught process of leadership transition in Hasidic courts. This is a gripping story about Hasidic Jews, but it is also about religious leadership more generally in the modern age.”—David Myers, Sady and Ludwig Kahn Professor of Jewish History at UCLA

Awards

  • National Jewish Book Award Finalist (American Jewish Studies Category) 2018, Jewish Book Council